| Year | Football | Golf | Track & Field | Wrestling | Swimming | Gymnastics | Cross Country | Basketball | Tennis | Baseball | Hockey | Soccer | |
| 2024 | Texas Tech | Penn State | Arizona State | Stanford | Connecticut | Denver | |||||||
| 2023 | Michigan | Florida | Arkansas | Penn State | California | Stanford | Oklahoma State | Connecticut | Virginia | LSU | Quinnipiac | Clemson | |
| 2022 | Georgia | Texas | Florida | Penn State | California | Stanford | Northern Arizona | Kansas | Virginia | Mississippi | Denver | Syracuse | |
| 2021 | Georgia | Pepperdine | LSU | Iowa | Texas | Stanford | Northern Arizona | Baylor | Florida | Mississippi State | Massachussets | Clemson | |
| 2020 | Alabama | Northern Arizona | Marshall | ||||||||||
| 2019 | LSU | Stanford | Texas Tech | Penn State | California | Stanford | BYU | Virginia | Texas | Vanderbilt | Minnesota Duluth | Georgetown | |
| 2018 | Clemson | Oklahoma State | Georgia | Penn State | Texas | Oklahoma | Northern Arizona | Villanova | Wake Forest | Oregon State | Minnesota Duluth | Maryland | |
| 2017 | Alabama | Oklahoma | Florida | Penn State | Texas | Oklahoma | Northern Arizona | North Carolina | Virginia | Florida | Denver | Stanford | |
| 2016 | Clemson | Oregon | Florida | Penn State | Texas | Oklahoma | Northern Arizona | Villanova | Virginia | Coastal Carolina | North Dakota | Stanford | |
| 2015 | Alabama | LSU | Oregon | Ohio State | Texas | Oklahoma | Syracuse | Duke | Virginia | Virginia | Providence | Stanford | |
| 2014 | Ohio State | Alabama | Oregon | Penn State | California | Michigan | Colorado | Connecticut | Southern Cal | Vanderbilt | Union | Virginia | |
| 2013 | Florida State | Alabama | Florida Texas A&M |
Penn State | Michigan | Michigan | Colorado | Louisville | Virginia | UCLA | Yale | Notre Dame | |
| 2012 | Alabama | Texas | Florida | Penn State | California | Illinois | Oklahoma State | Kentucky | Southern Cal | Arizona | Boston College | Indiana | |
| 2011 | Alabama | Augusta State | Texas A&M | Penn State | California | Stanford | Wisconsin | Connecticut | Southern Cal | South Carolina | Minnesota Duluth | North Carolina | |
| 2010 | Auburn | Augusta State | Texas A&M | Iowa | Texas | Michigan | Oklahoma State | Duke | Southern Cal | South Carolina | Boston College | Akron | |
| 2009 | Alabama | Texas A&M | Texas A&M | Iowa | Auburn | Stanford | Oklahoma State | North Carolina | Southern Cal | LSU | Boston University | Virginia | |
| 2008 | Florida | UCLA | Florida State | Iowa | Arizona | Oklahoma | Oregon | Kansas | Georgia | Fresno State | Boston College | Maryland | |
| 2007 | LSU | Stanford | Florida State | Minnesota | Auburn | Penn State | Oregon | Florida | Georgia | Oregon State | Michigan State | Wake Forest | |
| 2006 | Florida | Oklahoma State | Florida State | Oklahoma State | Auburn | Oklahoma | Colorado | Florida | Pepperdine | Oregon State | Wisconsin | UC Santa Barbara | |
| 2005 | Texas | Georgia | Arkansas | Oklahoma State | Auburn | Oklahoma | Wisconsin | North Carolina | UCLA | Texas | Denver | Maryland | |
| 2004 | Southern Cal | California | Arkansas | Oklahoma State | Auburn | Penn State | Colorado | Connecticut | Baylor | Cal S. Fullerton | Denver | Indiana | |
| 2003 | LSU Southern Cal |
Clemson | Arkansas | Oklahoma State | Auburn | Oklahoma | Stanford | Syracuse | Illinois | Rice | Minnesota | Indiana | |
| 2002 | Ohio State | Minnesota | LSU | Minnesota | Texas | Oklahoma | Stanford | Maryland | Southern Cal | Texas | Minnesota | UCLA | |
| 2001 | Miami | Florida | Tennessee | Minnesota | Texas | Ohio State | Colorado | Duke | Georgia | Miami | Boston College | North Carolina | |
| 2000 | Oklahoma | Oklahoma State | Stanford | Iowa | Texas | Penn State | Arkansas | Michigan State | Stanford | LSU | North Dakota | Connecticut | |
| 1999 | Florida State | Georgia | Arkansas | Iowa | Auburn | Michigan | Arkansas | Connecticut | Georgia | Miami | Maine | Indiana | |
| 1998 | Tennessee | UNLV | Arkansas | Iowa | Stanford | California | Arkansas | Kentucky | Stanford | Southern Cal | Michigan | Indiana | |
| 1997 | Michigan Nebraska |
Pepperdine | Arkansas | Iowa | Auburn | California | Stanford | Arizona | Stanford | LSU | North Dakota | UCLA | |
| 1996 | Florida | Arizona State | Arkansas | Iowa | Texas | Ohio State | Stanford | Kentucky | Stanford | LSU | Michigan | St. John's | |
| 1995 | Nebraska | Oklahoma State | Arkansas | Iowa | Michigan | Stanford | Arkansas | UCLA | Stanford | Cal S. Fullerton | Boston University | Wisconsin | |
| 1994 | Nebraska | Stanford | Arkansas | Oklahoma State | Stanford | Nebraska | Iowa State | Arkansas | Southern Cal | Oklahoma | Lake Superior State | Virginia | |
| 1993 | Florida State | Florida | Arkansas | Iowa | Stanford | Stanford | Arkansas | North Carolina | Southern Cal | LSU | Maine | Virginia | |
| 1992 | Alabama | Arizona | Arkansas | Iowa | Stanford | Stanford | Arkansas | Duke | Stanford | Pepperdine | Lake Superior State | Virginia | |
| 1991 | Washington Miami |
Oklahoma State | Tennessee | Iowa | Texas | Oklahoma | Arkansas | Duke | Southern Cal | LSU | Northern Michigan | Virginia | |
| 1990 | Colorado Georgia Tech |
Arizona State | LSU | Oklahoma State | Texas | Nebraska | Arkansas | UNLV | Stanford | Georgia | Wisconsin | UCLA | |
| 1989 | Miami | Oklahoma | LSU | Oklahoma State | Texas | Illinois | Iowa State | Michigan | Stanford | Wichita State | Harvard | Santa Clara Virginia |
|
| 1988 | Notre Dame | UCLA | UCLA | Arizona State | Texas | Nebraska | Wisconsin | Kansas | Stanford | Stanford | Lake Superior State | Indiana | |
| 1987 | Miami | Oklahoma State | UCLA | Iowa State | Stanford | UCLA | Arkansas | Indiana | Georgia | Stanford | North Dakota | Clemson | |
| 1986 | Penn State | Wake Forest | SMU | Iowa | Stanford | Arizona State | Arkansas | Louisville | Stanford | Arizona | Michigan State | Duke | |
| 1985 | Oklahoma | Houston | Arkansas | Iowa | Stanford | Ohio State | Wisconsin | Villanova | Georgia | Miami | Rensselaer | UCLA | |
| 1984 | BYU | Houston | Oregon | Iowa | Florida | UCLA | Arkansas | Georgetown | UCLA | Cal S. Fullerton | Bowling Green | Clemson | |
| 1983 | Miami | Oklahoma State | SMU | Iowa | Florida | Nebraska | UTEP | NC State | Stanford | Texas | Wisconsin | Indiana | |
| 1982 | Penn State | Houston | UTEP | Iowa | UCLA | Nebraska | Wisconsin | North Carolina | UCLA | Miami | North Dakota | Indiana | |
| 1981 | Clemson | BYU | UTEP | Iowa | Texas | Nebraska | UTEP | Indiana | Stanford | Arizona State | Wisconsin | Connecticut | |
| 1980 | Georgia | Oklahoma State | UTEP | Iowa | California | Nebraska | UTEP | Louisville | Stanford | Arizona | North Dakota | San Francisco | |
| 1979 | Alabama | Ohio State | UTEP | Iowa | California | Nebraska | UTEP | Michigan State | UCLA | Cal S. Fullerton | Minnesota | SIU Edwardsville | |
| 1978 | Alabama Southern Cal |
Oklahoma State | UCLA UTEP |
Iowa | Tennessee | Oklahoma | UTEP | Kentucky | Stanford | Southern Cal | Boston University | San Francisco | |
| 1977 | Notre Dame | Houston | Arizona State | Iowa State | Southern Cal | Indiana State Oklahoma |
Oregon | Marquette | Stanford | Arizona State | Wisconsin | Hartwick | |
| 1976 | Pittsburgh | Oklahoma State | Southern Cal | Iowa | Southern Cal | Penn State | UTEP | Indiana | Southern Cal UCLA |
Arizona | Minnesota | San Francisco | |
| 1975 | Oklahoma | Wake Forest | UTEP | Iowa | Southern Cal | California | UTEP | UCLA | UCLA | Texas | Michigan Tech | San Francisco | |
| 1974 | Southern Cal Oklahoma |
Wake Forest | Tennessee | Oklahoma | Southern Cal | Iowa State | Oregon | NC State | Stanford | Southern Cal | Minnesota | Howard | |
| 1973 | Notre Dame Alabama |
Florida | UCLA | Iowa State | Indiana | Iowa State | Oregon | UCLA | Stanford | Southern Cal | Wisconsin | St. Louis | |
| 1972 | Southern Cal | Texas | UCLA | Iowa State | Indiana | Southern Illinois | Tennessee | UCLA | Trinity | Southern Cal | Boston University | St. Louis | |
| 1971 | Nebraska | Texas | UCLA | Oklahoma State | Indiana | Iowa State | Oregon | UCLA | UCLA | Southern Cal | Boston University | Howard | |
| 1970 | Nebraska Texas Ohio State |
Houston | BYU Kansas Oregon |
Iowa State | Indiana | Michigan | Villanova | UCLA | UCLA | Southern Cal | Cornell | St. Louis | |
| 1969 | Texas | Houston | San Jose State | Iowa State | Indiana | Iowa | UTEP | UCLA | Southern Cal | Arizona State | Denver | St. Louis | |
| 1968 | Ohio State | Florida | Southern Cal | Oklahoma State | Indiana | California | Villanova | UCLA | Southern Cal | Southern Cal | Denver | Maryland Michigan State |
|
| 1967 | Southern Cal | Houston | Southern Cal | Michigan State | Stanford | Southern Illinois | Villanova | UCLA | Southern Cal | Arizona State | Cornell | Michigan State St. Louis |
|
| 1966 | Notre Dame Michigan State |
Houston | UCLA | Oklahoma State | Southern Cal | Southern Illinois | Villanova | UTEP | Southern Cal | Ohio State | Michigan State | San Francisco | |
| 1965 | Michigan State Alabama |
Houston | Oregon Southern Cal |
Iowa State | Southern Cal | Penn State | Western Michigan | UCLA | UCLA | Arizona State | Michigan Tech | St. Louis | |
| 1964 | Alabama Arkansas Notre Dame |
Houston | Oregon | Oklahoma State | Southern Cal | Southern Illinois | Western Michigan | UCLA | Southern Cal | Minnesota | Michigan | Navy | |
| 1963 | Texas | Oklahoma State | Southern Cal | Oklahoma | Southern Cal | Michigan | San Jose State | Loyola | Southern Cal | Southern Cal | North Dakota | St. Louis | |
| 1962 | Southern Cal | Houston | Oregon | Oklahoma State | Ohio State | Southern Cal | San Jose State | Cincinnati | Southern Cal | Michigan | Michigan Tech | St. Louis | |
| 1961 | Alabama Ohio State |
Purdue | Southern Cal | Oklahoma State | Michigan | Penn State | Oregon State | Cincinnati | UCLA | Southern Cal | Denver | West Chester | |
| 1960 | Minnesota Mississippi |
Houston | Kansas | Oklahoma | Southern Cal | Penn State | Houston | Ohio State | UCLA | Minnesota | Denver | St. Louis | |
| 1959 | Syracuse | Houston | Kansas | Oklahoma State | Michigan | Penn State | Michigan State | California | Notre Dame Tulane |
Oklahoma State | North Dakota | St. Louis | |
| 1958 | LSU Iowa |
Houston | Southern Cal | Oklahoma State | Michigan | Michigan State Illinois |
Michigan State | Kentucky | Southern Cal | Southern Cal | Denver | ||
| 1957 | Ohio State Auburn |
Houston | Villanova | Oklahoma | Michigan | Penn State | Notre Dame | North Carolina | Michigan | California | Colorado College | ||
| 1956 | Oklahoma | Houston | UCLA | Oklahoma State | Ohio State | Illinois | Michigan State | San Francisco | UCLA | Minnesota | Michigan | ||
| 1955 | Oklahoma | LSU | Southern Cal | Oklahoma State | Ohio State | Illinois | Michigan State | San Francisco | Southern Cal | Wake Forest | Michigan | ||
| 1954 | UCLA Ohio State |
SMU | Southern Cal | Oklahoma State | Ohio State | Penn State | Oklahoma State | La Salle | UCLA | Missouri | Rensselaer | ||
| 1953 | Maryland | Stanford | Southern Cal | Penn State | Yale | Penn State | Kansas | Indiana | UCLA | Michigan | Michigan | ||
| 1952 | Michigan State | North Texas | Southern Cal | Oklahoma | Ohio State | Florida State | Michigan State | Kansas | UCLA | Holy Cross | Michigan | ||
| 1951 | Tennessee | North Texas | Southern Cal | Oklahoma | Yale | Florida State | Syracuse | Kentucky | Southern Cal | Oklahoma | Michigan | ||
| 1950 | Oklahoma | North Texas | Southern Cal | UNI | Ohio State | Illinois | Penn State | CCNY | UCLA | Texas | Colorado College | ||
| 1949 | Notre Dame | North Texas | Southern Cal | Oklahoma State | Ohio State | Temple | Michigan State | Kentucky | San Francisco | Texas | Boston College | ||
| 1948 | Michigan | San Jose State | Minnesota | Oklahoma State | Michigan | Penn State | Michigan State | Kentucky | William & Mary | Southern Cal | Michigan | ||
| 1947 | Notre Dame | LSU | Illinois | Cornell College | Ohio State | Penn State | Holy Cross | William & Mary | California | ||||
| 1946 | Notre Dame | Stanford | Illinois | Oklahoma State | Ohio State | Drake | Oklahoma State | Southern Cal | |||||
| 1945 | Army | Ohio State | Navy | Ohio State | Drake | Oklahoma State | |||||||
| 1944 | Army | Notre Dame | Illinois | Yale | Drake | Utah | |||||||
| 1943 | Notre Dame | Yale | Southern Cal | Ohio State | Indiana Penn State |
Wyoming | |||||||
| 1942 | Ohio State | LSU Stanford |
Southern Cal | Oklahoma State | Yale | Illinois | Rhode Island | Stanford | |||||
| 1941 | Minnesota | Stanford | Southern Cal | Oklahoma State | Michigan | Illinois | Indiana | Wisconsin | |||||
| 1940 | Minnesota | Princeton LSU |
Southern Cal | Oklahoma State | Michigan | Illinois | Michigan State | Indiana | |||||
| 1939 | Texas A&M | Stanford | Southern Cal | Oklahoma State | Michigan | Illinois | Indiana | Oregon | |||||
| 1938 | Texas Christian | Stanford | Southern Cal | Oklahoma State | Michigan | Chicago | |||||||
| 1937 | Pittsburgh | Princeton | Southern Cal | Oklahoma State | Michigan | ||||||||
| 1936 | Minnesota | Yale | Southern Cal | Oklahoma | |||||||||
| 1935 | Minnesota | Michigan | Southern Cal | Oklahoma State | |||||||||
| 1934 | Minnesota | Michigan | Stanford | Oklahoma State | |||||||||
| 1933 | Michigan | Yale | LSU | Iowa State Oklahoma State |
|||||||||
| 1932 | Southern Cal | Yale | Indiana | Indiana | |||||||||
| 1931 | Southern Cal | Yale | Southern Cal | Oklahoma State | |||||||||
| 1930 | Alabama Notre Dame |
Princeton | Southern Cal | Oklahoma State | |||||||||
| 1929 | Notre Dame | Princeton | Ohio State | Oklahoma State | |||||||||
| 1928 | Georgia Tech | Princeton | Stanford | Oklahoma State | |||||||||
| 1927 | Illinois Yale |
Princeton | Illinois | ||||||||||
| 1926 | Alabama Stanford |
Yale | Southern Cal | ||||||||||
| 1925 | Alabama | Yale | Stanford | ||||||||||
| 1924 | Notre Dame | Yale | |||||||||||
| 1923 | Illinois Michigan |
Princeton | Michigan | ||||||||||
| 1922 | California Cornell Princeton |
Princeton | California | ||||||||||
| 1921 | California Cornell |
Dartmouth | Illinois | ||||||||||
| 1920 | California | Princeton | |||||||||||
| 1919 | Harvard Illinois Notre Dame Texas A&M |
Princeton | |||||||||||
| 1918 | Michigan Pittsburgh |
||||||||||||
| 1917 | Georgia Tech | ||||||||||||
| 1916 | Pittsburgh | Princeton | |||||||||||
| 1915 | Cornell | Yale | |||||||||||
| 1914 | Army | Princeton | |||||||||||
| 1913 | Harvard | ||||||||||||
| 1912 | Harvard Penn State |
Yale | |||||||||||
| 1911 | Penn State Princeton |
Yale | |||||||||||
| 1910 | Harvard Pittsburgh |
Yale | |||||||||||
| 1909 | Yale | Yale | |||||||||||
| 1908 | LSU Pennsylvania |
Yale | |||||||||||
| 1907 | Yale | Yale | |||||||||||
| 1906 | Princeton | Yale | |||||||||||
| 1905 | Chicago | Yale | |||||||||||
| 1904 | Michigan Pennsylvania |
Harvard | |||||||||||
| 1903 | Michigan Princeton |
Harvard | |||||||||||
| 1902 | Michigan | Harvard Yale |
|||||||||||
| 1901 | Michigan | Harvard | |||||||||||
| 1900 | Yale | ||||||||||||
| 1899 | Harvard | Harvard | |||||||||||
| 1898 | Harvard | Yale Harvard |
|||||||||||
| 1897 | Pennsylvania | Yale | |||||||||||
| 1896 | Lafayette Princeton |
||||||||||||
| 1895 | Pennsylvania | ||||||||||||
| 1894 | Yale | ||||||||||||
| 1893 | Princeton | ||||||||||||
| 1892 | Yale | ||||||||||||
| 1891 | Yale | ||||||||||||
| 1890 | Harvard | ||||||||||||
| 1889 | Princeton | ||||||||||||
| 1888 | Yale | ||||||||||||
| 1887 | Yale | ||||||||||||
| 1886 | Yale | ||||||||||||
| 1885 | Princeton | ||||||||||||
| 1884 | Yale | ||||||||||||
| 1883 | Yale | ||||||||||||
| 1882 | Yale | ||||||||||||
| 1881 | Yale | ||||||||||||
| 1880 | Princeton Yale |
||||||||||||
| 1879 | Princeton | ||||||||||||
| 1878 | Princeton | ||||||||||||
| 1877 | Yale | ||||||||||||
| 1876 | Yale | ||||||||||||
| 1875 | Harvard | ||||||||||||
| 1874 | Yale | ||||||||||||
| 1873 | Princeton | ||||||||||||
| 1872 | Princeton | ||||||||||||
| 1871 | |||||||||||||
| 1870 | Princeton | ||||||||||||
| 1869 | Princeton Rutgers |
||||||||||||